The Ultimate Landlord Scam List: 10 Deposit Deductions That Are 100% Illegal
⚠️ Important Disclaimer:
This guide is for educational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Rental laws vary by state and country. It is your responsibility to research your local tenant rights and lease agreement before taking action. If you need legal assistance, consult a qualified attorney or your local housing authority.
📌 Why Tenants Lose Their Deposits to Illegal Deductions
Many tenants blindly accept security deposit deductions, assuming their landlord has the final say. But in reality, many common deductions are completely illegal—and landlords get away with them because renters don’t know their rights.
This guide will reveal: ✅ How to spot fake “damage” charges ✅ When landlords can & can’t charge for cleaning ✅ State-by-state laws on legal vs. illegal deductions ✅ How to fight back & get your deposit returned
By the time you finish reading, you’ll know exactly how to protect your money and challenge unfair deductions.
🚨 10 Illegal Security Deposit Deductions Landlords Try to Get Away With
❌ 1. Charging for Normal Wear & Tear
What’s Illegal: Landlords cannot deduct from your deposit for normal wear and tear. This includes minor scuff marks on walls, faded paint, light carpet wear, and loose doorknobs.
What’s Allowed: Major damages—like large holes in walls, broken appliances, or ruined carpets—are valid deductions.
📌 Pro Tip: If your landlord tries this, demand an itemized statement detailing the exact “damage” they’re charging for.
❌ 2. Charging for Pre-Existing Damage
What’s Illegal: You cannot be charged for damage that existed before you moved in. Some landlords falsely claim old damage is your fault to keep more of your deposit.
How to Protect Yourself:
- Take move-in photos and videos on Day 1.
- Fill out a move-in condition report and have your landlord sign it.
- Keep written documentation of any pre-existing issues.
📌 Pro Tip: Send a copy of your move-in documentation via email so there is a timestamped record of your rental’s initial condition.
❌ 3. Unreasonable Cleaning Fees
What’s Illegal: Landlords cannot charge for routine cleaning if you leave the rental in reasonable condition.
What’s Allowed: If you leave behind excessive dirt, stains, or trash, they can charge a cleaning fee.
📌 Pro Tip: If your lease doesn’t specify required cleaning standards, argue that the charge is unnecessary. If professional cleaning is required, demand a receipt for services rendered before paying.
❌ 4. Deducting for Minor Nail Holes
What’s Illegal: Small nail holes from hanging pictures are not considered damage in most states.
What’s Allowed: If you drilled large holes or mounted heavy wall items, you may be charged for repairs.
📌 Pro Tip: Check your lease for specific wording about wall repairs, and request a prorated deduction if repainting an entire wall is unnecessary.
❌ 5. Forcing You to Pay for Routine Maintenance
What’s Illegal: Landlords must pay for normal maintenance (e.g., replacing old appliances, fixing leaks, pest control for common infestations).
What’s Allowed: If you caused damage through neglect (e.g., not reporting a leak, leading to mold growth), they can deduct the repair cost.
📌 Pro Tip: Ask for a breakdown of repair costs and ensure the charge reflects only tenant-caused damage, not general upkeep.
❌ 6. Withholding Deposits for Paint & Carpet Replacement
What’s Illegal: Most landlords cannot charge tenants for full carpet or paint replacement unless the damage is excessive.
What’s Allowed: Large stains, pet damage, or burns may justify a deduction.
📌 Pro Tip: Many states require landlords to prorate costs based on the carpet or paint’s age. If they try to charge for full replacement, challenge them on depreciation.
❌ 7. Deducting for an Unapproved “Professional Cleaning”
What’s Illegal: If your lease does not require professional cleaning, your landlord cannot charge you for hiring a cleaning company.
What’s Allowed: If professional cleaning is explicitly required in your lease, they can charge you—but they must provide receipts.
📌 Pro Tip: If hiring a professional cleaner is required, get the service done yourself and provide a receipt to avoid overcharges.
❌ 8. Charging for Trash Removal When You Left the Place Clean
What’s Illegal: If you properly dispose of your trash before moving out, your landlord cannot claim extra “trash removal fees.”
What’s Allowed: If you leave excessive garbage behind, they can deduct disposal costs.
📌 Pro Tip: Take photos of the empty rental before leaving to prove there was no trash left behind.
❌ 9. Withholding Your Deposit Without a Written Explanation
What’s Illegal: In most states, landlords must provide an itemized statement of deductions within 14-30 days of move-out.
What’s Allowed: If you caused significant damage, they must list each repair and provide receipts.
📌 Pro Tip: If they refuse to send a statement, demand a full deposit refund immediately. Follow up with legal action if necessary.
❌ 10. Deducting for “Lease Break Fees” Without Agreement
What’s Illegal: If your lease does not include early termination penalties, your landlord cannot invent fees after the fact.
What’s Allowed: If you signed a lease stating you owe a fee for breaking your contract early, they can deduct that amount.
📌 Pro Tip: Ensure that any fees deducted comply with your state’s tenant-landlord laws on early termination fees.
⚖️ How to Fight Back & Get Your Deposit Back
If you suspect unfair deductions, follow these steps to fight back:
📝 Step 1: Demand an Itemized Statement
✔ Request a written breakdown of all charges. ✔ If they refuse, cite state laws requiring itemized deductions.
📩 Step 2: Send a Deposit Demand Letter
✔ Write a formal letter requesting your deposit back. ✔ Include a deadline (e.g., 10 business days) before you escalate the matter. ✔ Send it via certified mail for documentation.
⚖ Step 3: File a Complaint or Small Claims Court Case
✔ File a complaint with your local tenant rights board. ✔ If your landlord refuses to return the deposit, take them to small claims court. ✔ In many states, you can sue for up to 3x the deposit amount if the landlord acted in bad faith.
🎯 Final Thoughts: Protect Yourself From Landlord Scams
✔ Know your state’s laws before signing a lease. ✔ Document your rental’s condition before moving in and out. ✔ Demand an itemized deduction list for any withheld deposit. ✔ Send a formal demand letter if you suspect a scam. ✔ Take legal action if necessary—many tenants win their cases in small claims court.
📌 Need a hassle-free move-out cleaning? Book a trusted service Here and ensure your rental is spotless—so there’s no excuse for unfair deductions.
For more expert tenant protection tips, visit ExitCleanExperts.com today